Review: Etude House Miss Tangerine Sweet Shower Lips

1.30.2012


Etude House has been steadily rising in profile ever since Sandara from 2NE1 became their main model. To be honest, I think she looks pretty hideous in the picture above :P But the fact she is (barely) pulling off all that ridiculous orange-ness is a testament to her beauty. Honestly, I did not try these for a long time because I thought if Sandara looks this bad with that lipstick, I hardly want to try it myself. Then I saw the swatches on Musings of A Muse and decided I should give em a try. Also I adore to this day my Etude House Orgel Light lipstick, so figured why the heck not ;)


Purchased at/Cost: From Ebay seller zinopark for $11.99/each. Now they're $9.99/each *sigh* Go figure.


Packaging: Super nice! Lots of attention to detail and the sheer weight of them feels expensive (seriously, these are remarkably heavy!). I love how the boxes line up when you lay them side by side and the satisfying little clicks the wheel makes when you turn it. The tubes have a pearly coat on them that looks expensive and pretty cute. I like how the overall style is sleeker than their usual pink-overload.

1: Twist the dial little by little until you have enough for just one use.

I do have a complaint though. The directions say to twist just enough product for one use (aka 1~2 mm). If you don't and accidentally twist out too much, well it sucks for you because you can't really "twist it back in." You'll need to gently push it back in with you finger. Also, you can't actually twist out more than 3-4mm at a time. Given, you probably will never need to, but just saying - the reason they ask you to just twist out 1-2mm at a time is because CAN only twist out that much at a time.


Scent: AH-MAH-ZING! I guess I shouldn't be surprised since the Orgel Light smelled so nice. It's basically a tangy tangerine scent, surprise surprise.

Texture: It's pretty slick and smooth overall, BUT sometimes a little chunk of glitter will fall off the stick. Also if you look closely, there is a certain graininess to the texture :\ In a nutshell, it's tolerable but nothing to write home about.


Formula: This will sink into EVERY FINE LINE you have on your lips. It is also extremely unforgiving on chapped lips. Thankfully, the colors are light so this tends not to be obvious, but honestly, the formula could've been better. The upside is that this is pretty moisturizing/not drying.

Pigmentation: Not as pigmented as they appear on hand swatches and in the tube I assure you. Etude House lip colors are, as a general rule, lean towards the sheer, glossy side. Think of it as lip tint in a stick. If you want a lot of color, this is not for you. However, these ARE more pigmented than their Orgel Light line (at least compared to the one I have).

Lasting Power: Not that great. It's a tinted sort of lipstick (at least on me it is), so it lasts no more than 4-5 hours really.


#5 Sweet Peach Shower
Of the two colors I got, I like #5 the best. I find that orange/coral based colors suit me the most. As you can see, this accentuates fine lines and chapped lips like nobody's business, but does leave a very nice hint of color and shine. The orange color turns more pink/peach on my lips; I do like this color a lot, it reminds me of a glossier, more glitter-y NYX Pumpkin Pie. It is very reminiscent of tangerine indeed!


#1 Shiny Pink Shower
As usual, I look a little sick with this blue-based color. It looks okay overall, but it's not a color that looks particularly flattering on me. Like #5, this one sinks into fine lines, leaves a lovely shine, and a scale 1-10, this is a 5 in pigmentation. I don't use this one anymore because it looks garish on me.

#5: Sweet Peach Shower
I was trying to get a Natural Sunlight shot but my hair turned out rather nice so I vainly posted the whole pic ;) This is what #5 looks like after a few hours. You can still see a hint of color but most of it has faded away. I really like the gloss it leaves behind though. It also seems to be pretty moisturizing as lipsticks go (despite accentuating fine lines when you put it on). This is a fairly accurate shot of what the color looks like most of the time - a peachy pink tint. Like I said, I like how this color looks on me. I don't wear #1 anymore as it tends to make my lips look rather purple from far away.

Overall
Would I recommend this? Ehhhh....sort of.

Pros: packaging appearance/weight, great scent, fairly wearable, gorgeous shine, decently moisturizing/not drying
Cons: sinks into every line it can find, not long lasting, slightly grainy formula

This is one of the products that I feel lukewarm about. I don't hate it but I don't really think anybody is missing out either. Try it if you like, but don't expect anything amazing. I think it would mostly depend on how the color turns out on you and unless you have an Etude House shop near you, it'll be luck of the draw.  I won't be purchasing more personally and I wouldn't highly recommend it to anyone.

7 comments :

  1. Yikes. Doesn't sound too great. There are better out there. I think I will pass.

    www.thegirlieblog.com

    ReplyDelete
  2. Wow, it definitely doesn't seem nearly as pigmented or glossy as the ad picture, how misleading of Etude~
    I totally know what you mean about "Eeehhh lukewarm." I noticed a lot of those type of lip tint/stick products when I was in Korea, fun to try if you've got the spare change, but really just for fun (and for the cute packaging, lol).
    Thanks for the review~ 

    ReplyDelete
  3. sweet peach shower is so pretty on you!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Dara!! lol i think the shade looks good on u but i find that blue based pinks aren't the most flattering for my skintone either. and etude house stuff mainly just looks really cute, i find their stuff is pretty mediocre haha but it's soooo cheap in korea so can't complain i suppose!

    ReplyDelete
  5. It looks pretty, it's too bad it's so grainy :( You hair looks lovely though!

    ReplyDelete
  6. I lovee dara.my favorite from 2ne1. Yahhh... Im not really digging the orange look. Like why did they choose orange out of all the very flattering colors. Hahaha but i like tthe pink colored one. Looks cute but i think im gonna have to pass on this one cuz buying it in the states will definitely be pretty expensive, maybe if i go to korea. Thxss for the review!

    Ohh btw i tagged you to a award post. Hope you do it :)

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Labels